American elm (Ulmus americana)
red (slippery) elm (Ulmus rubra)
Ulmaceae, the elm family
How to recognize elms. Elms have leaves that are alternately arranged, simple in complexity, and are doubly serrate, meaning that the leaf margins have both small teeth and large teeth. (The teeth have teeth, basically.)
American elm, shown below, has moderate-sized leaves that are smooth or slightly rough-textured above, although not quite as scratchy as the leaves of red elm (Ulmus rubra).
Red elm leaves are generally larger than those of American elm, and very rough above.
The shape of open-grown elms is distinctive. It has been described as “a wine glass, a feather duster, or a colonial lady upside-down.” This is an American elm.
This is red elm.
Flowers and fruits. The flowers of elm are perfect (i.e., having both stamens and a pistil) but are “incomplete” in that they are missing something. In this case, as befits a wind-pollinated plant, there are no petals. The ones shown here are American elm.
The fruits are coin-shaped samaras–single-seeded and winged for wind dispersal. Differences in the fruits offer the clearest way to distinguish American and red elms ans American elm samaras are hairy-edged, while those of red elms are not.
Red elm fruits have hairless margins.
Bark. American elm bark is deeply fissured, soft, light-colored.
Red elm bark is hard, dark, and shallowly fissured.
American elm can be distinguished from red elm by snapping off a little piece of bark and observing the cross-section. It is chocolate-vanilla-chocolate-vanilla (alternating light and dark bands) whereas in red elm it’s chocolate-chocolate-chocolate-chocolate (two slightly different shades of brown).
See below, red elm, dark alternating with dark.
In the winter. Elm twigs have winter buds directed to one side of the twig. The leaf scars are oval, with about six well-defined bundle scars. The twigs of red elm are especially rough, and the bud scales are hairy as well. Those of American elm are hairles or only finely hairy.
Where to find American elm. E. Lucy Braun, in The Woody Plants of Ohio (1961, 1989; The Ohio State University Press) tells us that American elm is “Found in a variety of sites: frequent on alluvial bottomlands and along ravines, and sometimes a constituent of mesic woodlands northward. Often an early invader of cleared land and slumped banks, but not usually persisting on dry sites. Attacked by the Dutch elm disease and phloem necrosis which have killed large numbers of trees”
Where to find red elm. E. Lucy Braun, in The Woody Plants of Ohio (1961, 1989; The Ohio State University Press) tells us that red elm is “Ranging through most of the Deciduous Forest, in well-drained mesic sites and rocky (calcareous) hillsides. Well distributed in Ohio, usually ocurring as scattered individuals. The wood is dark brown or red, the inner bark fragrant and mucilaginous, characters which gave given rise to the commoin names., Easily recognized by the rusty winter buds and very rough twigs and leaves.
Scanned Drawing from an Old Book
Flora of West Virginia, by P.D. Strausbaugh and E.L. Core
Oooh ooh. I have a question!
What is that centipede-like pattern on the bark-free dead elm trunk, and how is it significant?
These are galleries of an elm bark beetle. The larger central channel was made by the egg-laying female, and the numerous smaller side channels were made by her offspring that eventually emerged. The beetles spread an introduced vascular tissue-blocking fungus that causes a lethal condition known as Dutch elm disease.